A day at 5th Avenue | Inside Starfish and StarCity, Part 1

One unexceptional Wednesday reveals the chaos of everyday life inside a Starfish recovery house

It was a cold February morning in Richmond. After several days without a functioning central heating system during the harshest winter stretch of the year, the 5th Avenue recovery house had finally warmed up again.

Inside, at least 11 men were beginning their day at the home operated by Starfish Recovery & Wellness. 

They had arrived with a range of needs and risks, including medical conditions, mental health challenges and — in some cases — active withdrawal from opioids or other substances. Some came with little more than the clothes on their backs and were relying on food banks or help from their housemates to eat. 

Despite the complexity of the men’s circumstances, the 14-bed house was operating without any formal oversight. It was neither licensed as a residential treatment program nor certified as a recovery residence. 

The home was designated as a “PHP house.” During the day, residents were required to attend off-site group counseling through StarCity Behavioral Health’s Partial Hospitalization Program (PHP).1 

Gray two-story historic house with white trim, metal roof, front porch, and fenced yard under a clear blue sky
Starfish’s 5th Avenue recovery house sits in Richmond’s Highland Park neighborhood. (Photographed by the author in 2026)

A little after 7 a.m., the house manager began updating the home’s group chat, removing residents who were no longer there — in the previous two days, two had been kicked out for unknown reasons, and four had been transferred to other houses to make room for new arrivals.

Around that same time, the men began lining up outside the house manager’s bedroom to receive morning medications. All prescriptions were held in a lockbox, accessible to the house manager and daytime staff. They often included blood pressure drugs, anti-psychotics and anti-seizure medications, as well as controlled substances such as Suboxone, Xanax and Adderall. 

The house manager, whom I’ll call Steven, was himself a StarCity patient.2 He entered StarCity’s PHP three months earlier, completed that portion of the program and was still receiving treatment through its Intensive Outpatient Program (IOP) while managing the home and overseeing other patients.

Steven was also on probation for drug possession charges incurred six months earlier. His criminal record spanned 26 years and included mostly drug and larceny offenses, as well as a 2009 unlawful wounding conviction. Probation records dated February 2015 identified Steven as a confirmed member of a violent prison gang. The records also showed he was subject to special probation conditions imposed on validated gang members. 

Despite his status as a current patient and his own history of drug-related offenses, Steven had access to residents’ medications and sensitive personal information, including Social Security numbers, which were sometimes shared in staff group chats on Facebook Messenger.3

Medical note for Amber Nicole mentioning cane use, independence with daily activities, and planned arrival on the bottom floor.
Screenshot of a message showing an email intake note with redacted identification and Social Security number details.
The top message depicts Starfish COO Amber Deaton sharing a patient’s date of birth and Social Security number in a group chat of at least 15 people, including Starfish and StarCity employees and house managers. The bottom shows Steven retrieving a patient’s date of birth and Social Security number from the company’s client management software.

Around 7:45 a.m., a driver arrived at the 5th Avenue house. Residents filed into a 14-passenger van for the 20-minute ride to Starfish and StarCity’s recovery center on Forest Avenue in Henrico County, where they would spend the day participating in PHP treatment.

One resident, whom I’ll call Kyle, stayed behind. Kyle had moved to 5th Avenue from Starfish’s Edgewood house, where he had relapsed three weeks earlier. StarCity had delayed his clinical assessment while waiting for his Medicaid coverage to take effect. During that wait, Kyle relapsed again. 

When he finally underwent the assessment the previous day, he told staff he had decided to enter a different treatment program. The next morning, he was told he had to leave by 8 because the house manager would be gone and he couldn’t stay in the house by himself. 

Minutes before the deadline, Steven reported that Kyle would have difficulty moving out on time because he needed to get to the methadone clinic that morning. Starfish COO Amber Deaton instructed Steven to change the door code when he left. 

Screenshot of a message from Steven about Kyle leaving for a clinic appointment at 8:45 a.m.
Screenshot of text messages discussing Kyle coming to the clinic, asking who he is, and requesting a door code change.

Back at the center, the other 5th Avenue residents reported to their designated PHP groups. The five-hour sessions typically began with a “feelings check,” during which patients took turns describing how they were feeling that day, according to former patients. The rest of the day could include curriculum activities, time outside and movie clips. Former patients and one facilitator also described behavioral and mental health challenges in the groups, including aggression, paranoia and patients who nodded off or slept through sessions.

The center was also a place where patients could hear Starfish and StarCity CEO Frank Bellanger screaming at employees in the hallway or behind closed doors, his voice carrying through the building, according to six employees who left the organization this year. (More on that later.)

After lunch, a flurry of messages in the group chat revealed considerable confusion among staff about whether Kyle — the resident whom had been told to leave by 8 a.m. and for whom Amber had instructed Austin to change the door code — was staying or leaving.

Screenshot of a text conversation about Kyle staying, with messages dated February 4, 2026.
Message from Steven: "It did but this morning he said he was still trying to leave."
Screenshot of a message thread discussing whether a man left or stayed, his location, a center assessment, and a methadone clinic visit.

After several additional messages, the confusion over Kyle’s situation was eventually resolved, and he returned to the 5th Avenue house. 

[View the full message thread.]

Later that afternoon, another 5th Avenue resident, whom I’ll call Derek, was sent back to the house so a nurse could meet him there and change his bandages.

Derek had arrived at Starfish five days earlier, testing positive for fentanyl, cocaine and methadone. He came with “A LOT” of medication and was “nodding a lot,” according to a staff chat. 

He also had an injury that required regular bandage changes. The chat did not specify the nature of the injury, but one employee recalled that it was from a recent gunshot wound.

During the nurse’s visit, Derek became agitated. Steven reported that he was yelling at the nurse and behaving aggressively. He wrote that Derek appeared to need a higher level of care and posed a threat to staff.

Screenshot of a nursing note describing a dementia patient’s aggressive and disrespectful behavior toward a nurse, refusal of dressing care, and possible need for higher-level treatment.

Nathan, an employee who had been in recovery for two years, responded that he had the situation “under control,” but Steven pointed out that the behavior was becoming a pattern.

Screenshot of a message from Nathan stating that he is supervising the situation and the woman is removing her dressing.
Screenshot of a message from Steven about someone getting loud again and raising the recurring issue, dated February 4, 2026.

After the nurse’s visit, Nathan reported that Derek’s medical needs were more serious than staff could manage. The nurse had removed a medical pump, and Derek would need assistance with daily wet-to-dry bandage changes to avoid infection. Nathan ultimately agreed with Steven that Derek might need a higher level of care.

Less than an hour later, during random inspections, Nathan reported finding a knife, unlabelled pills and unidentified liquids in a bedroom shared by Kyle and another resident. 

Screenshot of a staff message reporting a knife, unlabeled pills, and unknown one-gallon jugs of liquid found during a room inspection.

Later messages confirmed Kyle had failed a drug test, and at least one employee shared in the group chat that he felt Kyle needed a higher level of care due to repeated relapses. 

Despite staff concerns, reports of contraband, behavioral problems and significant medical needs, both Kyle and Derek remained at 5th Avenue. Both were placed on the schedule for StarCity’s PHP.

Later that evening, Amber ordered staff to search the entire house because she said there were weapons, homemade alcohol and medication “all over the house.”

Screenshot of a message from Amber Nicole requesting residents gather in a common area while staff search the house for unauthorized medications and weapons.

A little after 7 p.m., residents piled into the company van with Nathan to attend a local 12-step meeting. A second employee stayed at the house to receive a new resident transferring from another organization, where he had relapsed two days earlier. (The employee had just completed his own recovery program two months before and had a pending charge of assault and battery against a family member.)

Later that evening, Nathan finished entering the medications for a resident, whom I’ll call Jason, who had arrived two days earlier with nine days’ clean and a severe seizure disorder.

As soon as Nathan reported completing the task, Amber instructed him to bring all of Jason’s medications to the center the following morning. There were so many, from two different providers, that she wanted a physician to review what he was taking and determine what he needed.

Amber also emphasized that Jason had to receive his seizure medication, writing: “Only thing I do know is he takes 1000mgs of Keppra Am and Pm and if he doesn’t come get meds yall have to get him.” 

The exchange raises questions about the screening of residents’ medical conditions before they arrive, the responsibility placed on nonclinical staff to oversee residents’ medication needs and the two-day delay in recognizing that Jason’s medication regimen required a physician’s review. (Amber did not respond to a request for comment.)

Screenshot of a messaging conversation discussing returning Jason's medication to the center and arranging a neurology appointment.
Screenshot of a text conversation about reviewing a man's medications, including 1000 mg of Keppra taken morning and evening.
Screenshot of a conversation showing messages about a severe seizure disorder and arranging transportation.

A little after 11 p.m., Nathan completed the intake process for the new resident, uploaded a shift report and went home for the evening. 

Steven would be the only person in charge through the rest of the night at 5th Avenue. Before he went to bed, he completed a walkthrough at the house to make sure all the residents were still there and breathing.4

Message from Steven stating that the walkthrough is complete and everything will be ready for pickup by 7:45.

By some measures, it had been a relatively uneventful day. No one had been hospitalized, found high, assaulted or kicked out at the last minute. But that was only one day at the 5th Avenue house.

The next installments will take a closer look at the people who were brought there and what happened throughout their stays — from residents who arrived with serious medical conditions or mental health needs to those with histories of violence. The series will also examine Starfish and StarCity’s operations more broadly, including the circumstances surrounding another stabbing.

Please subscribe for updates, and get in touch with me if you’d like to share your experience with Richmond recovery housing.

>>Explore previous reporting on Starfish Recovery & Wellness


Note: As I’ve reported over the last few years, Starfish owners Frank and Stephanie Bellanger asked that I cease all contact with them in May 2023. I have not heard from either of them as I’ve continued reporting on Starfish. As always, if they choose to respond to this story, I will promptly add their comments and publish a notification of the update.


All reporting published on this site is free and accessible to everyone. But producing it takes considerable time and resources. If you value this work and would like to help sustain it, please consider becoming a monthly supporter. See my Sept. 2026 announcement to learn more.

Choose the monthly amount that works for you:

Need to make a change? You can cancel at any time.

Tax disclosure: Investigate RVA, LLC is not exempt from taxation under § 501(c) of the Internal Revenue Code. Contributions are not tax-deductible on your income tax returns.


Scroll below to view investigative stories in The Parham Papers series, or visit the homepage to explore all articles, including legislative updates.

1. Despite the name, Partial Hospitalization Programs for people with substance use disorder typically don’t involve hospitals. [Return to article]

2. In staff communications reproduced in these stories, I use aliases for house managers, who are often program participants themselves, and I identify non-executive employees by first name only. This approach applies only to names appearing in the staff communications, not to sources interviewed for these stories. [Return to article]

3. Many of the staff communications shown throughout this series were exported from Facebook Messenger. The exported images preserve the messages and timestamps but look different from screenshots taken within the Messenger app. [Return to article]

4. Amber explained the purpose of bed checks in a Starfish peer leader chat on Dec. 16 — to ensure that residents were home, alive and breathing. [Return to article]

Screenshot of a group chat discussing bed checks to ensure residents are home, alive, and breathing as a safety precaution.

Leave a Reply